The many pluses and minuses of Alexa Plus | The Vergecast

I'm so sorry to everyone. We should have warned you. >> Oh yeah. Turn off all your devices. >> Mute your devices. >> Sorry. >> Hello and welcome to the Burgecast, the flagship podcast of the Alexa Plus shopping list. I'm your friend David Pierce and today on the show we're going to talk about the smart home, specifically Alexa Plus, which is going through a bunch of changes right now. Amazon has been on a run of hardware announcements, new Ring stuff, new Kindle stuff, and today a new Alexa tablet, which is maybe the most surprising new Amazon device in years. All of it centered around the idea of getting Alexa Plus deeper and deeper into your life. Plus, Gen 2 on our team has spent the last year testing Alexa Plus, and she has some thoughts about it. But first, here's what else is happening on The Verge today. This is 90 seconds on the Verge for Thursday, October 8th, 2026. Some big news in the red-hot world of domain names. Ian, the governing body for names and numbers on the internet, just released a batch of 1,600 applications for new tople domains. Those are mostly called tldds, and they represent the thing on the other side of the dot in your URL.com or.gov, but also pizza andai and everything else. The new batch is surprise all about AI. A bunch of big companies like Meta and OpenAI are fighting to own the aagent andagi domains while lots of companies are also trying to get their own brands turned into URLs. So you can imagine URLs ending infas and chatgpt and even apparently Applebees all appear to be on the way. In an AI world, do we even type domains anymore? I don't know, but everybody still clearly wants the good ones. Meanwhile, we're only a few weeks away from the launch of Grand Theft Auto 6, the most anticipated game in I don't know, forever. There have been a lot of leaks already, including a brand new one that shows one of the main characters running around Vice City naked because this is GTA and that's what we do. You can also get in the mood for the game by going to Rockstar's website to listen to one of six of the games radio stations or a bunch of the fictional podcasts made by fictional podcasters that will be available while you play the game. Frankly, I'm just outraged that the Vergecast won't be there. And finally, Joe Rogan and Spotify have made a new deal. This one apparently worth around 250 million to keep the show on the platform. The Joe Rogan experience is messy and complicated, but it is still the biggest show in the space. So, I guess it's not hard to see why Spotify still wants it. You can read more about all this at the verge.com. That is 90 seconds on The Verge for Thursday, October 8th, 2026. All right, let's talk Alexa. The Verge is Jen 2 is here. Hi, Jen. >> Hi, David. So great to have you back. >> Jen, I have been thinking about you a lot over the last several weeks because a a thing that happens when you go on parental leave is you have a lot of time just sort of milling around your house where you're like legally not allowed to leave because there's a newborn baby nearby, but also they're asleep and you don't want to make any noise. And so what I've been doing is just rining every single smart device in my house. And it has driven me insane in ways that I was not sure I was able to be driven insane. Yeah, I can I've been go I went through something quite similar actually recently and yeah, it's uh it's it's kind of like spring cleaning though, right? It it feels good once it's all all done, but during that process, you want to tear your hair out. And there was there were real moments of like going through my Alexa app and deleting devices that not only do I not use that I have absolutely no recollection of ever using that are just somehow connected to my smart home system and realizing which bridge with 50 numbers at the end was which like there is something cathartic about the end of the process but it is awful. Especially the Alexa app. Wow. >> Oh it's so terrible. >> Really bad. >> It's so so so bad. They used to be able to go to the Alexa website many moons ago and you could delete things there and I miss that so much. >> Oh, that would be so much better. Or here's a world. You should be able to ask Alexa this. >> Yay. What a good idea, David. >> Which brings me to what we are here to talk about. So, there's kind of two important things happening in Amazon land right now. One is Amazon is in the middle of a giant slew of hardware launches, new Kindles, new Ring stuff. There's a new Alexa tablet that just came out today. All kinds of stuff happening. And then on the other side, uh, you have now been testing Alexa Plus, the the supposed revolution in voice assistance from Amazon for a year and and you you put together a whole big piece on kind of what your experience has been and how you're feeling about Alexa. And these two things are obviously very tied together, right? This hardware is about Alexa Plus in meaningful ways. They are about baking Alexa plus into more things and more parts of your life. So, I think we should start with Alexa Plus. A year in, you've been testing it. You've been living with it. You're you're you're deep in this zone. How are you feeling about Alexa Plus? We don't talk about it as a sort of general purpose right up there next to, you know, Claude and Gemini and all the others. But my sense is that has always been the goal of Alexa Plus. Do you feel like it's getting there? So yeah, that does feel like the goal to be a sort of chat GPT or even a a Claude or even a Muse now that Muse is arrived with its and it has smart home integrations. Um although I've not really found a lot of use for them yet, but you can see that path like your AI agent controlling your home makes a lot of sense. Amazon already has an AI agent in Alexa plus. Shouldn't Alexa plus then also be your personal AI agent? I and this could be because of my bias towards the smart home, but I just want my smart home assistant to be my smart home assistant. I don't like the bringing together. It hasn't worked for me. If it worked, maybe I would feel better. >> But this the ambition of Alexa Plus to be more than the smart home assistant hasn't sold me yet. It is doesn't I I find that it's attempts to break outside of its mold. um generally are frustrating and I'm not able to finish the task that I I gave it. So I I end up just having to go to my phone or go to my computer and it's like why did I even start this a different way? I should have just started from my phone. I've just wasted my time. But as a smart home assistant, everything that Amazon has been working on over this last year has started to come to fruition. I do feel like everything that it used to be able to do that it was frustrating because it didn't always do it well has got much better when I first started testing this. So it was in beta. I started in like July. It didn't actually launch properly until February. >> Mhm. >> So now since February it's been available for anyone that wants to use it. Um either with a Prime membership or you pay $20 a month. If you pay $20 a month for Alexa plus I would like to hear from you. Um, but yes, I've been testing it for over a year and most of that time has been okay. Amazon says this is this is our product, use it. And that has steadily got better. >> So, give give me a sense of what better looks like here because I think if if I were to on the smart home front in particular, if I were to think about the things that Amazon was promising, it was essentially much more conversational use, right? You don't have to learn the language. You don't have to get the syntax exactly right. You don't have to name all of your lights and remember what they're all called. You can just more functionally and more humanely talk to your home. That was one big one. And then the other one was you can do much more complicated stuff through that interface. Right? They had lots of ideas about routines and lots of ideas about how to put all these things together. And the idea was just >> we are going to radically simplify the interface and thus make it more powerful on the other side. Is that is that a fair way to describe kind of what they've been trying to do? >> Yeah. And I think they're they're halfway to that p more powerful. That's what's got a lot better. Like especially you were talking about um setting up routines. Being able to set up routines with your voice is like the game changer. Um because going into an app, fiddling with things like that, that's just not something that people generally have a lot of time or patience for. But being able to just say, "Hey, I want the lights to turn on at this time every night and I want you to lock the door at this time every night." And just say that to an your Echo Show and it does it for you. That is a a great experience and it works. And if it does it wrong or if there's something you don't like about it, you can go into the app and you can go and change it. Um, what we're still what I'm still missing and what I'm really hoping is going to be sort of the next wave is really deep integration with your devices. Right now there's a a lot of turn on and off or you can you can do this but you can't do that. I that next layer where your smart home assistant can control everything that your connected device can do is is where I I'm hoping that they're moving. Case in point like right now smart lights are great. I can say to my assistant turn all the lights in my office purple and it will do it. Um, I can say turn all the lights to a nice sort of sunsetty glow and it will do it. But I still can't get it to do things like say set my washing machine to the delicate cycle because it doesn't have integration that deep. What we need is that more fine grain control the Alexa to have. And this is something that we're starting to see and is a real value of the smart home when it becomes to these AI agents because the more data that you can feed into an agent, the more it can do for you. And you know you to your point earlier that this is where Amazon's moving. Is Alexa going to become like your personal assistant as well? >> Ultimately I think Amazon really should stay in the smart home lane. That's what I would like to see. And then perhaps you could pull in your personal assistant and they could work together. And this is something that Google Homes started to offer. You can actually use um different you could they hasn't they've launched an MCP so you can use claude to control your Google Home. So I feel like there is a future where we have all these different AI agents working for us in different elements of our lives and that we can we can orchestrate and we can pull together. Um right now I'm not saying Amazon couldn't do this well but right now I don't feel like it has um the type of agentic things that Amazon has said Alexa can do for us. I have often just hit a roadblock when I've tried to use them, like ordering things from Uber Eats or booking trips or even booking tickets. I mean, occasionally it works and occasionally it doesn't and it's like, ah, that's just frustrating. But turning my lights on and off, managing my smart home, those things, it's doing much better. Not perfect. There's definitely still the occasional time where it goes off and does something just a little weird. Um or says something a little strange. Um but o but but overall it's been a big improvement since I first started testing it. Um and yeah, I I it's I mean it's one of it is the best smart home voice assistant you can use today. um in terms of functionality and understanding understanding what you want it to do um is is a big change and that that makes it much easier to use. >> Yeah, I actually think in a funny way it is it is kind of a perfect example of what LLMs do really well, right? Which is take you rambling nonsensically and turn it into something sensible. I mean, and right that in so many ways, if you just look at every AI tool that is working for people, it looks like that, right? It's meeting notes where like we're going to sit here and talk for an hour and it's it's going to pull out all the stuff that matters and give us action items at the end. There are a million tools that are actually pretty good at that now. And and this is very much the same thing where it can do a reasonably good job of figuring out what you meant without you having to perfectly exactly speak the language of the computer. And I think that's very exciting. I do think there are lots of things left to do there. Like I It's funny you bring up the washing machine example because one thing I've been thinking about a lot is uh when you have three kids, you do just an infinite amount of laundry. This is this has been the major new change in my life is just infinity laundry all the time. Um what I cannot figure out how to do is get my system in some way to alert me when the washing machine is finished. Right? And the the best version of that is I just have a washing machine that is connected to Alexa and it does it automatically and everything is great. those exist. They're they're very expensive and kind of wonky and I don't it's just that that it's not what I have. There's also something that's like, okay, my washing machine makes a noise. Can I set up Alexa to listen for that noise and alert me when it makes that noise? >> The answer seems to be like kind of I've like gone down this road enough to figure out that it like it maybe potentially theoretically is possible, but I can't make it work. And it's just one of those things that it's like there are so many little fiddly pieces of just being a person in a house that all of this stuff just the the long tail of this is going to be long for a long long long time. But just the fact that I can do like one thing I I was doing the other day was when I lock my front door, turn off the inside light and the outside light because we only lock our door at night. We live in a very safe neighborhood. If you want if you want to come rob me during the day, please do. Uh, but we we I when I lock the door, I want both of those lights to go off because it just means I'm going upstairs and going to bed. And that's that's like a simple routine that I could have programmed before but never did because it was just annoying. But I just set it once and it worked. And that is that is powerful. >> That is and and there is there is a way you can set Alexa to listen for a beep. Um, so you'd have to put an Echo in your laundry room and then listen for a beep. >> Okay. I have one but it's all the way across the room and I actually think that might be part of the problem. I might need to like sit it on top of the dryer. >> Yeah. But to your point there and and this is another area I've seen I have seen improvement with Alexa plus and this that goes to its agentic elements is that it needs to understand your home. It needs to understand your whole home. That's where the magic and the power will come. And now some of the improvements include um you can send things to it. You can feed data to it. So, like I can send it my daughter's school schedule and it will add it to my calendar. I can upload a recipe um you know from my from a cookbook or from a website and it will add it to my cooking library. And so those types of elements that are going to make working me working in my home and moving around my home and doing chores and getting things done in my home easier and better. I think it has made a huge improvement in how well those integrations work. Um, it's just once you try and move outside of the home for me that it has started to fall apart and I'm just like this this isn't I want I want the home to get better. >> I feel like it's I can see the path here and there's so much more that could be done. Um, and the improvements have been have been immense from when I first started testing it. Um, so yeah, it's and once it can understand all the context in your home, um, which you know, it's Amazon, so that's your choice if you want Amazon to know everything about your home. Um, but once it does have that context, like one one really good example, um, is the Ring integration. Uh, so, uh, the Ring camera. So if someone rings my doorbell, um, I get an alert and it comes up on my, um, show show smart display. If I miss it, I can say, "Hey, Alexa, when did the package get delivered?" And it will pull up the video, the last time that a package was delivered. And then it will also tell me what's in that package if it's from Amazon. >> Whoa. >> So, like you can just bringing all of the pieces and parts together and presenting you with that information. >> Creepy, yes. Useful also, yes. So, that's the balance, >> right? Well, this is why you can also see you can also see why it's so tantalizing to Amazon to try to branch out even further, right? Because we've talked about this many times on the show, right? Everybody's business plan for AI is shopping in some way, right? That Mark Zuckerberg is like, we'll get some portion of the money that you spend. Where are you going to spend that money is on places like Amazon. And I think to a large extent everybody is making this giant bet that if we can shrink the gap between you saw something or you you see something in your house, you just look at it and you go, "Oh, I need more. I need more of that." And it'll just order it for you, accomplish goal. Like >> this has been the dream of Alexa since the beginning, right? And you can see why Amazon looks at this and they're like, "Okay, we have better language understanding. We have vastly better processing. We actually have the requisite hardware in a lot of people's homes already. we have to go capture the rest of this. I think it's wrong and I don't think it's going to work. And I mean, there's just no evidence that this is actually a thing Amazon is good at is putting all of those pieces together, particularly in a way that doesn't just involve >> your Amazon information. >> Yeah. >> But you can see why Amazon can't help itself from trying, which is part of why I find Alexa so fascinating. >> Well, and it so they've promised since since this launch, they promised all these integrations that I was really excited for, like Expedia, so I could book a hotel or >> Right. This is supposed to be the whole thing. We talked about this that like Amazon was going to go make deals and do API work and actually really integrate this stuff in a way that might work >> and that it is not. I mean, >> no. And you know, the shopping is a great example because in my house, I make an Amazon shopping Alexa shopping list and then I want to order everything from there and I have to open my my shopping app from my other from my Harris ter and I have to transfer everything. I even tried like asking Claude if it could take a screenshot and put it in here for me. But no, I have to do all the manual work. If I shop from Whole Foods, Amazon will do it all for me, but I don't want to shop from Whole Foods. >> Amazon does not acknowledge the existence of other grocery stores. There is Whole Foods and there is nothing. they said you would be able to do this and they said you would be there's so many of these integrations with other companies that they promised and that still haven't come to fruition and that is just frustrating because it's it feels so close um but then it also feels like it's Amazon sort of locking in on its own like it's not letting news use Amazon.com and if we lock everything down and try and create these little wooled gardens for AI it's going to be a bad experience for everyone this this is the beginning of this. Everything has to be open more so than it ever was. And Amazon with its Alexa was the original open smart home platform. And I think it needs to lean back into that um and become the platform that people can use because that's the only way it's going to be really useful and successful. >> Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's Teamwork pulls all the pieces together from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the contacts with agents you already use like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at jira.com. That's jir.com. Support for the show comes from IDRA by Palo Alto Networks. Every new cloud workload or AI agent your team sends out is another identity that gets permanent access to your systems. And in 2026, those non-human identities with access outnumber actual human identities 109 to one. You need a tool built to manage them all. Human, machine, and AI. That's exactly what by Palo Alto Networks was designed to do. It's one identity platform for all and it outshines legacy tools that were only built to manage human employees. How does it work? Well, IDRA replaces permanent permissions with dynamic access. So, you can lock down every identity without slowing down your own business. With IDRA, you get unified control by replacing siloed AM or identity and access management, PAM, modern privilege access management, and governance tools, all with a single control plane. And it does that across human, machine, and AI identities. Secure every identity at your organization with IRA by PaloAlto Networks. Learn more at powaltoetworks.com/ir. Again, that's powoaltoetworks.com/dir A. Support for the show comes from Ring. Holiday shopping is easier than ever, but keeping track of packages showing up at your door is another story. But Ring can help give you peace of mind, whether you're traveling, at work, or just out running errands, all right from your phone. That means whatever shows up around your home this holiday season with Ring, you're protected. With Battery Doorbell 2K Plus, you can keep an eye on deliveries at your front door, so you can know for sure that your packages will be there when you get home. But there's more to your home than just your front door. Outdoor Cam Plus lets you check in on your yard and outdoor spaces with clear retinal 2K video that lets you zoom in and catch all the details. And for inside, the compact indoor cam plugs in almost anywhere, letting you easily check in on your home and pets when you're not there. Together, they make it easy to stay connected to what's happening around your home, wherever you are. With Ring, you're protected for the holidays. Shop cameras, doorbells, and more at ring.com. Support for the show comes from whatnot. When you're selling online, the unfortunate reality is that sometimes it can feel like you're shouting into the void. But when you sell on Whatnot, it's like cutting the line in front of your target audience. Whatnot is the largest dedicated live shopping platform. Whether it's beauty, collectibles, electronics, luxury, fashion, even cookies. Sellers are building real businesses. Anyone can sell whether your business is big, small, or yet to exist. People selling on whatnot sell tens more than on other major marketplaces. That's because you're not just listing products. You're building real connections with buyers. And consistency pays off. This isn't just a side hustle, but a real path to building something that lasts. What buyers spend more than an hour a day in the app. They're doing more than just browsing. They're engaging, buying, and coming back. You go live, show off products in real time, and turn what you love into real income. Search whatnot. W H A T N O T in the app store. Download and you can start selling right away. Amazon's been on a run of hardware and I think most of it makes sense, right? New Ring stuff, new Kindles. This all kind of makes sense for what Amazon is doing. They make better versions of old products. Um the Alexa tablet is kind of a wholly new thing. It is very much not a Fire tablet. It's $500. It it is a full-on Android tablet. It is it is designed to be a true iPad competitor kind of in every sense of the word, which is not a thing I thought Amazon would make. But I think the way you're talking about this where a they need something that works in more places outside of your home. They need something that has different kinds of context about you that maybe you end up either building a smartphone or a tablet. And if you're Amazon, you probably can't talk yourself into building a smartphone again. >> And you have Panos, who is the tablet guy, right? So, >> right. Oh, boy does that man love a tablet. Uh, but do you do you look at this tablet and just think, "Oh, this is the the logical extension of what they're trying to do with Alexa Plus." >> So, I obviously didn't see the tablet until after I'd finished my year in my review of Alexa and I was like, "Oh, well, this is what they're trying to do now. They're trying to make this is where they will get your contacts if you're doing all your work on your tablet." I you know if you're using Slack I mean because it's a full Android tablet. This is not a Fire tablet where which was frustratingly locked down. I know cuz my kids all had Fire tablets. This is like a full get things done. And so yes, they could get this is where the personal context can come. I believe that Alexa Plus can actually if with permission like read your screen and >> it's basically Siri like they're they're really trying to make it operate like Siri or Gemini in that it is baked all the way across the operating system which is a level of ambition we've really never seen from Amazon before in that way >> and it is I mean the next step would be a phone but this would give that personal context that they're currently missing um assuming you're going to everyone's going to go all in and this becomes their main interface but tablets are generally companion devices to computers. So, I I don't know. Is this going to Are you going to use this with your new Google book? I mean, I just don't see where it's going to fit into people's workflow. I can see that it's going to be a great tablet for kids. >> Um the the Fire tablets always have been, but it's, you know, I I I have the Pixel tablet up here. Um and I tried to sort of use that as a primary device because it has great smart home interface in controls, and I just never had a use for it. uh because I have my iPhone and I have my computer. So, I do think this is their move into okay, we can we can get your the personal context. We can be the more ambient assistant that's with you at home and on the go. And I'm sure we're going to see more devices that bring Alexa on the go, which we have in the past, but they've never been very successful. >> You know what's funny about that, by the way, is Amazon was early to every hardware trend. Like, they did rings before rings was cool. They did glasses before glasses was cool. Like I would not be at all surprised to see a bunch of that stuff come back out of the closet at Amazon now that there is actual market interest and they feel like they have tech that works cuz again this is this is if you're going to do it you have to do the whole vision right >> you have to everything. Yeah. Yeah. And I mean and I they need that whole ecosystem to really create this full personal AI assistant that's going to be both your home and your personal assistant. But there's still going to be friction between the two, especially because the home is a, you know, multi-user environment. Um, and that that's where things can quite easily go wrong. And that's why I feel like having an assistant in your home that really understands your home, knows what's happening in your home can be separate from your personal assistant, but that you can bring the two together. Um, but it'll be I mean Apple is allegedly going to be announcing a lot around the home coming up and that's going to be an interesting like reverse. They're trying to do what Amazon has already done. Um, and I'm it's going to be interesting to see how they are able to merge home with personal because it's it's tricky and it's it's a big challenge and if you're using AI, you want to give it some kind of agentic capabilities, which means doing things without necessarily checking. And that's where it's not so bad if it's on your phone, but when something like that happens in your home, that's a whole different ball game. So, um, yeah, it's it's it's interesting to watch these two companies kind of come at the problem from the opposite sides. >> We should actually talk about Apple for a minute because I think the the end of the Alexa Plus story seems to be that for all of its sort of outward flaws, it is still the best, most complete home system, right? Like that especially voice assistant. >> Yeah, >> home assistant people will stop me yelling at the screen right now. Sure. >> But I think also in terms of like plug and play, vastly compatible, almost anybody can figure it out. >> It it is it is ahead of the pack at this point. >> Um, and that's a that's a powerful thing for Amazon. And I think >> it's it's funny that Amazon still has the same problem as ever, which is what do we do beyond that? They just they've spent all this time trying to figure it out. And even with this new rev in the technology, they are still stuck on this same problem, which is what do people want to do with this technology? Yeah. >> of this sort of ambient awareness into the rest of your home. So, we we've seen some reporting that suggests there's going to be an Apple launch next Tuesday, the 13th. Uh we've seen some leaks of what appear to be LG made but Apple blessed smart home devices, which is a thing I find very confusing. >> Yeah. And it looks just like a Nest thermostat. >> Yeah. Whatever happens next week, you will be on top of it. We will be on top of it. We've talked about the the mythical HomePad device for a long time, but please don't call it a HomePad. >> Oh my god. If they call it a HomePad, I swear. See, I'm going back on parental leave. If they call it the HomePad, I can't. Um, but looking ahead to next Tuesday, what's what's kind of top of mind for you as you look at what Apple might be doing here? like this this would be Apple's real like two feet into the pool leap into the smart home game. >> What are you thinking about as you get ready for this? >> So the biggest thing for me is how is this is the Siri AI the Siri AI for the home because if they're they're launching a smart display. We have done smart displays. No one has really created the ideal smart display. Amazon's Echo devices are Echo Shows are the bestin-class right now. They got a lot better, but they still they're not they're not the sort of embodiment of artificial intelligence in your home. They're just an interface. >> Yeah, I still think the Pixel tablet was the correct idea and that everyone should be copying that, but that's that's another verse cast. >> RIP. Um, but yes, I what I think Apple can differentiate here and why I assume this has taken so long because they've been waiting for Siri AI to catch up is that the interface is the AI like it is not just a touchcreen. It is that it is much more deeply embedded into your smartome. So the Apple intelligence for the home is going to be I I'm hoping the differentiator here will be that it can really truly understand and control and to my point earlier about how Amazon needs to connect into everything and have control over all the devices not just on off I you know the things that work with Apple home intelligence in particular maybe these new LG devices but maybe this is what's going to differentiate them will have this sort of extra layer that can really where the Apple intelligence can really understand what's happening in your home. Take the context that it can get both from your personal and your communal devices and be a more proactive, more helpful, more um embedded assistant in the home rather than just a sort of interface that you control devices with. Um it's a big leap. It's what Amazon's been trying to do for a long time. And I think this really the only way that Apple can truly differentiate in this space is to do something to to take a big leap forward with Siri AI in the home because Siri in the home today very limited but we've seen the beginnings of the Apple intelligence for the home. did a piece a couple weeks ago about how um the video descriptions, the element, these new elements that Apple intelligence have brought to HomeKit secure video, it can describe what it sees in your home. All of that is data it can feed into understanding how your home runs and how you how you want things to happen in your home. And other leaks from um Bloomberg include a new camera that will potentially capture data without recording, which is going to be interesting to see. But this is another big challenge we've had in the home. >> If you feed the data, you get better results, but people don't want cameras >> keeping an eye on everything they do. So yeah, if if they can find that balance and really understand your home and what you need and what you want and respond proactively, that's going to be a really um killer product. Although I have a feeling that it's going to cost a lot of money. >> I agree. I'm I am really looking forward to seeing what kind of privacy case Apple makes here because I think even the Apple Watch feature recently where it's like it is where you can sort of go back and replay previous conversations like >> even that which is not quite as invasive as it is made out to be freaked people out and for good reason, right? So I think Apple is has a really tough needle to thread here to say we are doing all of the things that you find useful and we're going to do it in a privacy preserving way but also there's a camera. That is a hard hard case to make at this particular moment in our lives and the tech industry. >> It is it's it's going to be a big challenge. But I think for anyone that uses a smart home, we've always got to remember this sort of costbenefit ratio. Um I always I like to compare it to Gmail. like you use Gmail because it works really well and does make your life easier. Yes, there are some privacy payoffs and that's something you have to weigh. I would love to get to the point where the smart home is completely local and I've written about this at length but the value the value ad comes from connecting to the cloud in many instances and you know >> you just have to be able to sort of decide how much does this benefit me and is it worth potentially risking my privacy although Apple and Amazon they they do talk a very big talk about how well they protect your privacy. and how well they protect your data. So, it it basically comes down to who who do you trust with this information. Um, and I think our readership is probably skewing Apple, >> but also increasingly skewing nobody. >> That's very true. >> Right. And I think I think that's the hard that's the hard thing for all of these companies to deal with is there's there's the the climb is more and more uphill for everybody all the time. Right. As all the technology is starting to work, right? Like that is the it's the strangest piece of this to me is everything we've been waiting for for a decade is starting to become real in real ways right as everybody is starting to realize maybe we never wanted this and I think that that tension is like the only thing I care about in tech right now. I think it is so fascinating and it really comes to the head most with Apple all the time which is I think why it is so if anybody was going to trust a company it has been Apple for decades and even that is starting to erode and I find that fascinating. >> Well yeah I mean the the HomeKit secure video the new features they all use the cloud whereas the old HomeKit secure video didn't so you are having to give away more of your data. Um, this is something I wrote about a while back, but I really feel strongly I think eventually we're going to have get to the point where this all has to run entirely locally in our homes. It may it's going to be a more expensive upfront investment, but ultimately you're going to feel more comfortable and you know local AI it's going to be a a while I think until we get to the point where their capabilities are as good as what we have in the cloud. But I think we will get there. Um, I agree with you though. It's an interesting tension and the journey to that point and also whether it's valuable enough to spend the type of money you're going to need to spend in order to have something like this operate inside your home um is going to be it's a hard sell >> indeed. All right. Well, whatever happens next week, we will be back here talking about it. There's there's just a lot of smart home stuff coming. I have not made fun of you about matter in two months and I will not today, but I will very soon. But until then, Jen, thank you for being here. It's good to see you. >> You're welcome. All right, that's it for the show. Thank you to Jen for being here and thank you as always for watching and listening. I am sorry again for all of the times we set off all of your Alexa devices. There's one more. I apologize. If you have thoughts, questions, feelings, if you are using Alexa Plus for something cool and interesting and you want to tell us about it, I would absolutely love to hear about all of it. Send us an email vergecastverge.com. Call the Vergecast hotline 866 Verge11. We love hearing from you. And as a reminder, the best thing you can do to support all of this is to subscribe to the Verge. You get all of our podcasts ad free. You get our subscriber newsletters, everything. The verge.com/subsubscribe. Thank you in advance. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Josh Kahas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kefir, and Travis Laruk. We'll see you tomorrow. Rock and roll.