How much should you tell your AI agent? | The Vergecast

Hello and welcome to the Vergecast flagship podcast of secure password vaults in your text messaging. [music] I'm your friend David Pierce and today on the show we're going to talk about agentic AI messaging systems. So there's been all these new products right meta muse openai's dots instinct a bunch of other startups coming out all with the same idea that basically what you want to do is message with an AI assistant that will then use agents to go and accomplish stuff on your behalf. And I say stuff in the loosest possible way because they all have big different ideas about what you might want your agents to do. Allison Johnson on our team has been testing all of these. They're all very similar in certain ways and all very different in interesting and important ways as we try to figure out how people actually want to use AI. So, she's going to come on the show and we're going to talk through how we feel using these products, whether they're any good, and which one you should be using. All that is coming in just a sec. But first, here's everything else happening on The Verge today. I'm Travis Larch and this is 90 seconds on the Verge for Tuesday, October 6th, 2026. The 110 billion mega merger of Paramount and Warner Brothers Discovery is complete. The combined company is called Sky Dance and it includes Adult Swim, Alloy Entertainment, Animal Planet, BET, Bleacher Report, Boomerang, Cartoon Network, CBS, CMT, CNN, Comedy Central, Cooking Channel, DC Comics, Discovery, Food Network, Golf Digest, HBO, HGTV, Magnolia Network, MTV, Network 10, New Line Cinema, Nickelodeon, Own Paramount, Pluto TV, Pop TV, Quest, Science Channel, See It Now Studios, Shed Media, Smithsonian Channel, TBS, The Free Press, TLC, TNT, Travel Channel, Turk Classic Movies, TV Land, and Warner Brothers. Also, Amazon bought the rights to stream the Emmys. So, starting in 2027, you'll need to go to Prime Video to find out who wins among however many networks we have left at that point. More info keeps trickling out about the upcoming Fitbit Edge. The new leaked details shared by Deal Labs suggest it'll end up costing around $180 in the US and that it'll have an always on OLED touchscreen and offer up to 7 days of battery life so long as you don't leave the always on OLED touchcreen always on. And finally, PC Magazine reports that Trump Mobile appears to have suffered a data breach. The data set includes 3,615 people's names and contact information. I have nothing to add other than 3,615 is an awfully specific number. You can read more at theverge.com. That's 90 seconds on the verge for Tuesday, October 6th, 2026. >> All right, let's talk agents. The Verge is Alison Johnson is here. Hi, Alison. >> Hello. So, are you the kind of person who outside of journalistic responsibility would have downloaded an app like Muse and tried to find things to do with it? >> Boy, is that hard to know because I was told immediately that I would be using these things. I think it it appeals to me in the way that there are too many things to do and not enough time. Um, so, so yeah, maybe >> I guess maybe another way of asking this question was how hard was it for you to figure out things to do with all of these agent assistants? Because I think >> I've been I've been gone for a couple of months and all I have had time to do is sit and do things that only require one hand while I have a baby in the other hand. And one great thing to do is just goof around with weird AI assistants that claim to do things for me. And so in a funny way, I've been the like exact optimal target for these things in that I have stuff I need to accomplish and I need the simplest possible way to accomplish them, including like not having to type in hexadeimal passwords all the time. And uh I I understand that I am at like a very particular moment that is not representative of how most people experience these things. So what is it like for you? The the sort of cold start problem of like you've tested a bunch of these things. Do you open it up and immediately have a bunch of ideas in your head about how to use a product like this? It is a little bit of the blank page um kind of cold start effect where you're like, "Huh, what do I do? I what is my life?" Like, "Do I have to?" And then I don't know. I I was coming off of uh like an extremely busy week and I've been traveling. So, I sat down with Muse and uh it didn't take too long. Um I was like, "Okay, I do have a backlog of stuff that is just piled up." like my husband's been taking care of the kid alone for a week. He hasn't had time to deal with stuff. I have not had time to deal with stuff. So, there was a list of things that I could get it to do. Um, so that helps. Yeah. I I do think one of the things I always see on my social feeds, which I always enjoy, is the the people who defend AI are constantly like, "If you think people don't have giant endless tiny low stakes to-do lists all the time, you have never met a working parent." And like >> while that obviously doesn't describe everybody, boy do I agree with that thesis. Um, so you've you've tested recently you've tested Meta's Muse, you've tested OpenAI's Dots, and you've tested this app Instinct, which is a a startup that's running mostly through iMessage. I'm fascinated by your experience with those three in particular because I kind of think you've seen the spectrum of the ways this thing can work, right? Everybody, I mean e everybody is building this AI assistant. Every everybody is building a thing that you can message with that will go through things on your behalf. This is the only idea in Silicon Valley right now. Um the three flavors of it as far as I can tell are the three that you've tried, right? There's the one that lives in your existing messaging app. There's the one that just is a messaging app which is Instinct and Muse respectively. And then there's dots, which is a a feature that lives inside of a larger AI ecosystem, right? It's not it's not dots in an app, it's dots inside of chat GBT. >> Of those three, dedicated app, inside your messaging app, part of a broader AI thing, which feels right to you so far? Which have you gravitated to the most? >> They've all kind of like shown themselves to have different strengths to me. Um, but the one that strikes me as like the most useful in a dayto-day way and the least intrusive is Instinct. >> Um, because it is just in your messaging app and you just it's that makes it kind of everywhere and nowhere at the same time. Like I'll I'll think of something and I have my smartwatch on. So I'm like, "Oh, I can fire off a text to Instinct." you're in the car and you can you can do, you know, car play kind of things. Um, so and it's also the most like just to the point getting things done like the you're you're kind of constrained in that you're typing out a a little message on your little smartphone keyboard. You don't get long-witted responses. It's very like got it doing that thing or even just an emoji reaction. Um, which is funny. I'm like, "Don't don't pretend you're a person with [laughter] like a sense of humor." I don't know. >> Yeah. Anytime he gives me the the like thumbs up tapback emoji, I'm like, "You don't have thumbs? Get out of here. [laughter] What do you know about thumbs? >> You don't know about thumbs?" >> Um, I think I agree. And and part of the reason I've been thinking about this is I will say for like regular people, I'm I'm all the way out on the dots approach, right? And I think your experience with DOTS was that this is I think you called it work software that will order me a burrito. And I think that's exactly right. And I think that's very useful as far as it goes for people who will use it for business. >> I think that's a non-starter for regular people in their regular lives. Um Muse I think works because it feels like a messaging app and and obviously Meta is going to put Muse everywhere. It's it's in it's going to go in WhatsApp. It's going to go in Instagram. it's going to go like Meta will eventually percolate this to lots of messaging apps and I imagine that's where it will be very successful. The place where I'm torn is instinct is very understandable in the way that you just described, right? I I know what it is because it's a thing I text message. It doesn't have any pretense of being a thing that I've installed on my device. It doesn't try to ask for any kind of disk access. I I I know the box around instinct in a way that's really helpful. That also causes a bunch of problems. Like, have you ever had to uh open up the Instinct browser when it's trying to do something and it gets hung up on one of those proof you're a human >> uh moments? Have you ever had this happen? >> Not with instincts, but I did with Dots and it felt it felt weird. I felt like I was like like an underage kid with asking you to buy cigarettes or something, you know? >> So, for whatever reason for me with instinct, it runs into cloud flares. Prove you're a human thing >> all the time. And when you open up the browser, it opens up the browser in in the little thing and you have to then like mouse around and t and it just like that breaks, right? Because it it has to exist in these very specific confines. >> Yeah. >> But then with Muse, you get access to all that stuff and right it can do more things that way. It can more accurately connect to the connectors because it can just offer you a list of connectors that you can tap on. So like Muse is very simple in that way, but it's also more complicated. And I don't know, I've really gone back and forth between I have had that same experience that you have where it's really nice to just fire off a text message and not really think about any of the infrastructure around all of it, but to the extent that you kind of have to have some infrastructure, like you have to do a little bit of work to let it access your Gmail, it just is a little bit easier that way. I don't know. I've I've struggled with this. Muses felt more like if I'm sitting at my computer, which is funny, like, you know, as a meta product, but it it was more useful for me when I was sitting down. I didn't even necessarily have the desktop app open. I was like in a browser window. But then you have like more canvas. You can see its little computer that it's clicking around on. you just have that like quick clear view into like okay I have m I have my mouse controls to take over when I need to do that. Um yeah, instinct by its nature I think kind of like abstracts that away and it's just sort of like don't worry about it. Let me handle this. I got it. You sometimes get that like um secure login link to you know um get your your Gmail or whatever credentials stored safely etc. We love it. Um, you run into that sometimes and you're like, oh, this is this is software that, you know, [laughter] you're like, I see you behind the curtain. >> Um, >> there is an app running here. You're just not showing it to me, >> right? But otherwise, it's like you need just text messaging a very helpful little guy somewhere, [laughter] I guess. Yeah, I've really come around on it on that front because I think in the in the early days of some of these apps when most people were using it for, you know, clawed code and openclaw and stuff, I was like the idea of accessing this stuff through telegram just feels wrong. Like I I don't I I need a different kind of interface than just messaging. But for the stuff that these things do well, which is very basic one or twostep tasks, just send a text message actually kind of works for me. And I I've really come around on the idea that actually maybe I do want to message some AI system to accomplish things for me and maybe that's good enough. Um what's the most surprising thing that has worked for you in in testing these things? Either something that you like really pushed that worked and you didn't expect it to or something that worked, you know, in a in a way that you didn't mean it to but was cool anyway. Like what stuck out as kind of the the hero experience so far? >> Oh gosh, several things. First of all, Muse um as a shopping platform just so sleek and frictionless. It's like you get your credit card in there one time through like Stripe or whatever and it's like I'm just going to run all over the internet and buy things for you. >> Somewhere an army of Facebook ad product managers just got a [laughter] raise just the minute this published. >> Hats off. like [laughter] it's just like you don't even have to click a button. You just type the words go ahead and it just fires off the transaction for you. This is is like problematic in many ways for me personally in my bank account. Um but also just kind of like yeah the the product working as intended is is almost like too good for for those purposes. I think the other thing that kind of caught me off guard on like the other side of the spectrum um was working with dots. Um dot uh you know my personal dot which I called dotty >> dot has dots. I think it's dot and dots. >> Dot plural of dot is dot and also dots >> could also have dots. Yeah. Um my dot is named dotty mc dot face because I can't help myself. Um but I had uh I was trying to do all the like consumerish stuff. I was like, I am trying to set up a new ISP at my house and it was kind of clunky and like not working great for all that stuff. And I was like, oh, you just got to do work. Like this is just work software. So I I started like bossing it around and I was like, go update my personal website. And kind of came back with some stuff. And it has the option, I think a few of these do, maybe they all do, where you can like call it quote unquote and and like talk to it. This is a big feature of dot in particular though the the like voice mode assistant bit of it all. >> Maybe it's sort of like more present in a way where it's like you can just, you know, just call your dot. I was like that's going to feel weird and dumb and I don't want to do that. And I called it [laughter] and I was like um firing off just a bunch of stuff I wanted it to do. like it gave me a a draft like kind of proposal of what this website redesign would look like. I was like, I'm just going to talk to this thing for 10 minutes and say everything that's wrong with it and just kind of went like section by section. And I kept I kept being like, so you you're with me? You got all this? It's like, oh yeah, yeah, good. And then you just sort of like end the thing by being like, okay, can you go do all that? And it was like, yep, got it. And it it did like it did a pretty good job. We didn't, it wasn't um perfect, but I was like that actually was better than sitting and typing, you know, paragraphs of thoughts about what I wanted. Um, so it it was surprising in that like I was okay with it and I did not think I [clears throat] I wanted to talk to the robot on the phone >> that I have really struggled to adopt in my own behavior actually cuz I I think I'm so used to commanding computers that my instinct even when using one of these tools is to be very short and very direct and very sort of turn by turn like do this thing that I'm going to explain very clearly and in one sentence so that you don't get distracted. you're going to go do that thing and then I'm going to give you another sentence of things to do. And actually, there seems to be a lot of evidence that the best thing you can do is just ramble nonsensically at it for like 10 minutes and and that actually these tools are very good at distilling that into something more useful than you would have commanded it in the first place. >> It's really interesting. I just I am so bad at remembering to do that in using these tools. It makes more sense I think in work like you giving it a large data set which is just me rambling um as opposed to like I'm hungry get me a burrito you know is like not not quite the same uh use case but yeah although I I don't know the I find myself increasingly far apart from our commenters on how I feel about a lot of these things I think >> I think the my moral feelings about AI I I largely agree with our commenters. I think AI is is built on bad things. I think they I think it is run by companies that are doing bad things to the world. Like I think it's all bad. I think these products are actually really good and useful in a lot of ways. And I think the the cognitive dissonance of that is like the great question of our time. But >> right now I think like I look at the the Door Dash news from last week, right? Where they're like you can just you can just chat to Door Dash and say order me the thing that I got. I want that so bad in my life. Like once once a week, >> I'm lying. Four times a week, I go into the Toast app and I order the same thing from a coffee [snorts] shop and I go and pick it up. And if I could turn that from 10 taps in toast to just order the usual in a text message, that's good. That is that is a better user experience for me than being in a toast app. And this runs into I think the thing that you have been reckoning with a lot and I have been thinking about a lot while you know sitting on my couch on leave is the this question of is is that friction by definition a good thing right like you look at the comments on any piece that you've written about this stuff and you've talked about this on the show too all of the responses are why are you trying to automate being a person out of your life right and I think David ML and and Liz Leato and V Song did a great episode talking about this stuff like what does it mean to be a person is strangely important to being a technology journalist in 2026 in a way that I didn't like basic humanism [laughter] is at stake right now and and I I feel like for for you in particular you've had to really think about this in sort of a brass tax way like what what does it mean that I am giving these tasks and not these tasks way. Um, again I I think you are required by the virtues of your job to overindex on doing the thing like your own morals get sort of subjugated to what we need to do in order to thoroughly test these products. But how are you feeling about that? Like do you do you spend a lot of time with Muse and feel sort of icky in the way that like I feel when I look at Tik Tok for too long? God, I have a lot of thoughts about this. And it it sort of started to percolate when Google was adding the like automation stuff to Gemini like way earlier this year where it would it would like tap around on the Door Dash app and order some food for you. >> Sure. >> And you see it work once and it's sort of like, oh yeah, of course. like why wouldn't I do this version of just saying something to it and going hey order that thing for me rather than tapping around of like all things being equal I picked that one you know um but there's >> you know what's interesting there was a sorry I don't mean to interrupt but there was a really great piece in the Atlantic a week or so ago that made a a an argument I have not been able to stop thinking about that basically what we have done with technology is convenience our way out of ever interacting with people, right? And so instead of walking into a place full of people and talking to the person at the counter and having actual human interactions, >> we've all just reduced ourselves to I can do all the work on the screen. I find that argument incredibly compelling. Like if if you want to say throw your phone in the ocean, go talk to the barista. I'm here for that argument. I have a much harder time with the using Muse is a morally inferior tool than going into the Toast app to order to go. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. I think so much of our lives have already been kind of commoditized and automated anyway. And it's not like an endorsement of how we live, but it's like, [laughter] yeah, like I do place a to- go order with Starbucks as I'm running out the door. It means I don't talk to the barista. I I've had very lovely conversations with the barista at the Starbucks I go to. One of them like saw me come in throughout my pregnancy and I came in, she was like, "Did you have that baby?" I was like, "Yeah, I had that baby." You know, you have those women stuff right there. Yeah. >> That's the spice of life right there. But it's it's sort of like when you have the option for convenience and you live a life at the speed of, "Oh my god, we got to get to this kid's birthday party. We're late for it already and we just finished up the grocery shopping." You know, there are like your life is already has already accumulated so many tasks and things. You're like, "Yeah, I will automate this one thing." in and you know a a coffee at Starbucks is a a luxury and a convenience in itself but um yeah I god I think about this a lot. It's sort of like you know I think about my dishwasher. I love my dishwasher. I will not live without a dishwasher you know if I can help it. Um, would I gain something, I don't know, in in sort of like morally by doing my own dishes, you know, after every meal. Um, having that time to totally think, you know, about anything. I don't know. Maybe maybe I'm missing out on on some kind of like spice of life experience. Um, but you live in a like I just keep coming back to we live in a society, you know, and it's [laughter] like we have all of our our co-workers and bosses have dishwashers and if I was the one insisting on, you know, no, I I got to slow down and do all my dishes and my my friends are, you know, I don't know. It's a kind of a strange example, but I think we lived this out in a lot of little ways of like if I if I insisted on um I don't use email. If I was like I'm I use pen and paper and I'm going to uh talk to my colleagues that way like that. >> I call that Christopher Nolaning. if you decided to Christopher Nolan >> or like like Bill Murray can get away with the he's like >> like very elusive and will only you know contact you on his terms. >> He just appears at softball games and that's how you get in touch with Bill Murray. Yeah. >> It's like I think that works for Bill Murray. I don't think I have the same clout [laughter] to be like I will not be emailed. Um, so we're kind of we have to go along with the game. And I think there's there's a danger of I don't know things keep speeding up. It gets easier to put more tasks on your plate. So then you put more things on and you've got to automate more stuff. It it's it's it gives me a headache like every single day. I agree. And I think that is so much of the tension so many people feel with AI right now, right? There is this sense of even if I don't want it, if everyone else uses it, I will be left behind in some meaningful way, right? And it's like you you see all these things about people who uh don't want to use it but are using it every single day at work. And it's what be it's like well I don't want to get fired like at some point if I don't do this I fear getting fired or I fear not getting a job out of college so I have to use these tools in college even though they make me feel bad. I think that thing you just described where like well everybody else assumes I have a dishwasher is actually real and and important and and a complicated piece of this. And I think to some extent it's one of the reasons I like tools like Muse and Instinct because they don't then require you to jump through a bunch of hoops to access some of this stuff. It is like if if we are going to let this technology exist and I I mean that sincerely as an if and it is a question we should continue to ask at all levels of government and society for a long time. >> But if we're going to let it exist, it has to be this easy. And I think something like this is the right kind of easy in a way that like I've seen people in my life who never would have touched clawed code with a 10-ft pole >> using Muse and finding actually useful things out of it. >> And I think that's good. I like I have a hard time being against that even given all of my complicated feelings about AI. >> Right. Yeah. I think tool is the key word and I find myself using a mix of stuff. It's like there's stuff I'm going to go to Siri for. There's stuff that I would, you know, throw to an instinct or amuse. And it's they are all tools in the toolkit. And none of them has been my my personal AI assistant, you know, for everything. Support for the show comes from Amazon Prime. I know what you're thinking. It feels like you've blinked and suddenly it's October. Before you start asking yourself where the year went, ask yourself if you're ready for the holidays. If the answer isn't a confident yes, don't sweat it. [music] Prime big deal days is here. And that means 2 days of epic deals with new deals every day. October 6th and 7th only. Prime members can save on home decor, fitness gear, electronics, toys, and so much more. You can get something for everyone on your list and maybe something special for yourself, too. And it's all happening with plenty of lead time into the holidays. So, no more scrambling to come up with something last minute. The hardest part will be finding a good hiding place for it all. Sometimes the best gifts are the ones you just give. Well, because I'm constantly inspired by the people around me. And when I see something that reminds me of someone, I love being able just to get it for them. Whether I'm planning a gift weeks in advance or I just suddenly think of something at the last minute, Prime makes it easier to find something that feels right and get it when I need it. Prime big deal days is here. Shop deals now. Support for the show comes from Satellite. Every dog owner knows that sinking feeling. The one you get in the pit of your stomach when suddenly you realize that you don't know where your dog is. The satellite collar go is a GPS dog tracker that helps keep tabs on your dog with real-time GPS tracking, escape alerts, and intelligent monitoring. Real-time GPS location tracking, and virtual boundaries can help keep your pet out of danger while providing freedom. If you live on a large piece of land or in a rural location, or even just like to let your dog run off leash every once in a while, the Satellite Collar Go can give you peace of mind. But the Satellite Collar Go isn't just about tracking where your dog is. It's also about tracking their health. Satellite Sense AI helps you spot changes in your pet's health, particularly when you aren't there to watch. With satellite collar go, you can know where your dog is, what your dog's doing, and get insights into how your dog's feeling. Go to satellite.com to get 35% off with promo code Vircast. That's s a ti.com [music] to get 35% off with the promo code Vircast. satellite.com promo code birchcast. Support for the show comes from Framer. If you want to create a website that looks great, feels handcrafted, and comes together fast and seamlessly, then look no further than Framer. It's a complete website platform, not just a builder, so teams can launch and keep improving their sites in one place. It helps creators, teams, and businesses ship production ready sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. You're able to prompt, inspect, [music] edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. On Framer, agents and humans work in tandem. [music] Agents bring speed and scale, while people bring taste, judgment, and control. And that all takes place in the same workspace where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. Thousands of businesses from earlystage startups to Fortune 500s are choosing to build their websites in Framer, where changes take minutes instead of days. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a framer specialist or get started building for free today at framer.com/verge for 30% off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com/verge. Rules and restrictions may apply. Support for the show comes from Shopify. Starting a business requires you to be resourceful, and the more you flex that muscle, the more you start to see opportunities for growth. For example, launching your business with Black Friday approaching means you can take advantage of the extra online traffic. Shopify is there to help you make it all happen. Shopify is the platform for a record-breaking, reliable holiday selling season for businesses at every stage. Their pre-built website themes and AI site builder make it easy to launch a beautiful, professional looking store. And you don't ever need to touch a line of code to do it. They also have a mobile app that lets you run your store from anywhere. Their AI e-commerce expert, Sidekick, can help you manage almost any business tasks with a single prompt, including holiday discounts. With Shopify, you can easily sell everywhere people shop. Online, in person, across social media, and even in AI chats. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to shopify.com/vercast to start your free trial. That's shopify.com/vercast. Go to shopify.com/vercast today to hear your first Have you found yourself not doing things with AI on purpose? Like is is there a line in your mind where you're like, "Well, this is this is a task I really ought to do myself or I don't trust the AI to do this for some reason." Is there have you found that line? I kind of like try to challenge myself. I caught myself being really um like overeager to um have, [snorts] you know, whatever chat assistant is on my phone at the time just um look something up for me that I can't remember where you're like something's on the tip of your tongue. You're like, "What's the name of that thing that we saw? What's the band that blah blah blah?" Whatever. Those moments I'm like, "No, I'm going to work for this." And I [laughter] like Yeah. And it's not a new problem we've had. No, people have been saying that since like Google was invented. Like, oh no, Google, nobody has to remember movie names. >> Yeah, we're we're all going to be so dumb. Like, and there's something about it being as frictionless as I just yell at my phone and my phone is, you know, like across the table. I caught myself doing that more than once. I was like, you know, I could have come up with that if I had thought about it for more than two seconds. But that's like a little a weird little gem of like I'm I'm just gonna have this moment and really try and maybe I'll come up with it and maybe I'll just have to keep wondering for the rest of the day. I don't know. What about you? I think I agree with that. I I have definitely caught myself um looking for reasons to do things myself in an interesting way. Like I'll just give you one example. So, uh, my wife and I just had our third kid, and, uh, the immediate discovery upon having a third kid was that all of our cars are too small. Um, we have two of them, and they are both too small. Uh, [laughter] right now we have three car seats, and our our oldest sits in the middle and can literally like hit both of his siblings in the face simultaneously, [laughter] which he does many times, a car ride. Um, and so we're like, okay, we need a car with three rows. Um, I am pro minivan. Uh, Anna, my wife, is is just not ready to be a minivan mom, and that's okay, and I I accept her the way that she is. Uh, so we're in the middle of shopping for a bunch of cars. So I went to I think it was Muse that I did with this with. And I was like, "Okay, here here are my requirements. I need a car uh with three rows. I need a car with captain seats in the in the second row uh so that you can access the third row more easily. And I need it to be, I think I said, under 50,000 miles. Um, ideally a hybrid, but price over everything. Uh, and ever since then on Wednesdays and Saturdays, it has sent me >> just a bunch of car listings that might apply to me. >> And I had this moment of being like, this is useful in the sense that it's it's like sending me listings to cars that I maybe should buy. And at one point, it asked me a question that was literally like, do you want me to buy this one? And I responded yes to a previous message and it starts loading. And I was like, oh my god, did Muse just buy me a car? [laughter] It didn't. We stopped that from happening. But it was it was one of those things where I was like, "Okay, not only is this automating this process, this is actually a lot of work. I need to do myself. I need to I need to a go see what other cars are available other than the two that is identified for me. I need to go test drive those cars to see if they work. I need to spend a lot more time thinking about how much I care about like a new car versus used car." There's just like this is a thing that actually requires a lot of work from me to work for me and I cannot offload this. uh even though it actually it it successfully accomplished the task that I gave it >> and it was completely the wrong tool for that task. And that's just I've thought about that a lot for the last couple weeks. >> Um >> but it was it was the it was the it almost bought it for me thing that was actually the most alarming moment that [clears throat] I've had because it could have it had my credit card information, my my credit card against all rational economic, you know, incentives has a high enough limit that it could have just bought me a car. Uh, it shouldn't have and I would have been homeless very quickly, but it could have just bought me a car on my credit card. Um, >> oh, but that would have been such a good blog. [laughter] >> It would have been my favorite expense report of all time if I had just bought a car from Muse. [laughter] >> Sure. >> But it made me think about the the level of permissions I'm willing to give these tools. And again, I think you and I are both incentivized by our jobs to overindex on give it more information. And I think we've both been turned into a little bit of nihilists about this where it's like, well, I've already connected everything else to my Gmail. Like, what's one more? >> But I think like I I open the Muse app and you go to the connectors page and it's just every bit of personal information you could possibly ask for. It's it's your email, it's your calendar, it's your health data, it's your financial data, it's your medical records, it's everything. And the thing that has most broken my brain is that every single one of those you turn on and connect makes the product better in a in a in a direct linear way. The more data you give these tools, the better the tools are. They will do more stuff for you. They will make it more personalized. They will be more successful. It is just better in every way. And then on the one hand, I think you're you're completely insane to give all of that information to Meta. >> Meta in particular, all the promises it will make you, you should not believe Meta. You just I just I I don't know how to feel any way other than that. Meta's entire history suggests it is not a good steward of that data. >> Turn most of them on anyway because it may be better. >> Uh where is your head on this stuff right now? You're they want your passwords. They want your credit card information. They want access to all of the other apps that you use for everything. >> How are you feeling about turning all that stuff on in all these different apps? I feel yeah, probably I'm a little more liberal than I should be with the passwords. You give me like a a secure login vault and I'm like, okay, I feel pretty good about that. >> Well, you you use the word vault, so it's probably >> Yeah, right. I maybe I'm desensitized in the way that like I I live by my password manager and um it still kind of boggles my mind when I'm talking about password managers to people who are like but then the bad guys could just steal they could log into your password manager and steal everything. I'm like no no no no it's not like it's way better. >> But also like buddy if you get the password to my password manager I'm long dead. You know what I mean? Like go with God. >> Yeah. Yeah. I I just got to I got to move to the woods if that happens. I don't have anything left. But I think so I'm I'm constantly logging into new stuff on every phone that I test. Maybe that has desensitized me a little bit where I'm like, [snorts] what's another password manager thing? Like sure, have at them. >> And they want you to feel that way. To be clear, all of these all of these companies and all of these services are trying their hardest to make sure that we all feel that way. And it's really hard not to. >> Yep. And it it has worked. So I'm like I every website I've bought anything from in the past 10 years has some version of my credit card information and that gets hacked once a year anyway for you know whatever reason. So yeah there's a little bit of like oh what's one more. What would you tell other people though? Like if if I'm sure you've had the same thing I have where like I think Muse in particular has so sort of escaped containment that I again like people I would never talk tech about are asking me about Muse. I'm sure you've gotten the same thing. >> Yeah. >> What do you tell those people? What's the right reference framework there? >> You got to like listen to your gut on it. I think if you practice good password hygiene generally and you give it access to something like your email, it feels a little bit like a moat of well, it can't just run rough shot over every account that you have because it's all it needs is your email to get a two-factor authentication to get in something else. I don't know. I think my my advice is like, yeah, think about it. Be sure you know what you're going to get out of it and how that's going to benefit you and and like um yeah, just just do the right thing with your passwords to begin with. And hopefully that helps you when the when the robots decide to kill us all in 10 years. Yeah, the only the only I think pat advice I've come to on that front is only give it one credit card number and keep >> careful watch of that credit card. Um that's just like no matter how many cards you have, whatever, give it one number and check that account every damn day >> because like there just have been enough stories already of of weird things happening to people that like I I don't think Meta has any particular kind of malice. I don't like I don't think this is a scop to steal any your credit card information from Meta. If Meta wants to get your credit card information, it's it's like it's readily available. But uh [laughter] but there is this increasing set of evidence that suggests that these models and these tools will do things that are not predictable and that we don't expect and sometimes don't ask for. And uh I don't know if this has been your experience at least, but Meta at least is super thirsty. Like Muse is constantly like, "Hey David, here's a thing I found. Hey David, do you want to buy this thing? David, David, David, it's in your calendar. did you know that this is in your calendar? And I'm like, Muse, yeah, I put this in my calendar 15 minutes ago. Like, yes, I'm aware that this is in my calendar. Thank you very much. Uh, and you can just see, again, Meta in particular is really good at selling you stuff. And you can just see how >> much they want to shrink that line. And so, I'm like, if I if you want to give your credit card to Muse, I do not blame you. I also think you should look at your statement every single day. >> Yeah, cuz you might buy a car on accident. >> You [laughter] might buy a car by accident. Don't be like me, people. Only buy cars on purpose. That's a That's a pretty good rule to live by. >> Exactly. >> So, you've you've tested all of these now. What do you think's going to stick like in your in your sort of day-to-day life? Are you still finding yourself opening Muse, even having written about it to to do something? What What behavior still lingers? >> I haven't had I haven't gone back to Muse. I had I set up Instinct to do a thing every morning where it goes through my personal email and gives me the highlights. I'm like, tell just only tell me the things I got to pay attention to. And that has been like pretty useful. Um, so I'm like, all right, I'm going to I'm going to keep that checked on for now. Um yeah, if I if I come back to some kind of like enterprise software need, you know, I I can see like having Dot um do more stuff for me in that way of like I was like, why don't you go out once a month and find some like professional development opportunities? I'm like terrible about seeking those things out. I'm sure they're out there. and it it came back with some I was like, "Okay, uh, pretty good." Like those sort of things where it's maybe a regular cadence and it's something it's like, I know I'm gonna forget about this. It would be good for me if I had this information. Can you go find it? >> That's a good idea. Like like Yeah, those kinds of use cases. I'm like, I could live with this. Yeah, >> that's a very like souped-up Google alert thing, right? Like go find information that is relevant to me about this thing or at this time. I think that's that's useful and that seems to be a pretty sticky thing for a lot of people. We've seen this from uh Google did this with the the CC bot that it's it's marketing is like for families, but it'll go through your email and be like, "Here's your itinerary for the day." Uh I've heard from people who really like that. I get that email every morning and it does nothing for me because all of my stuff is in work accounts. So, that doesn't work. But, uh the the eternal Google problem of people have multiple Google accounts. But there is there is something to that basic just like there's a lot of information out there. Bring it to me sometimes that I think is actually pretty useful and I think these tools are really good at. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. All right, Allison, thank you. It's nice to see you again. Thank you for for dealing with all of my feelings. Uh and as you test more of these things, keep me posted. I'm I'm obsessed with the idea of like where where are you supposed to interact with these systems cuz I think these systems are coming and they're coming to every surface imaginable and I don't know that anyone has quite figured out exactly the right place for them. So if you if you find it you got to let me know. >> Best AI gadget is a smartphone [music] 2026. >> She's right again people. >> Yeah, good to see you. Thanks for having me. >> All right, that's it for the show. Thank you to Allison for being here and thank you as always for watching and listening. Quick thing before we go, just a small favor to ask. So, all three of the Veres podcasts, Vergecast, Virgin History, and Decoder have been nominated in the Signal Awards, which is a [music] big awards thing for podcasts. It's very cool, very exciting. We're really glad to be nominated. And I'll be honest, it would be really great to win. So, if you could go vote for us, the link is in the show notes. Please vote for Vergecast, vote for version history, and I suppose if you have to, if you just like happen to have time on the side, also go vote for decoder, [music] I guess. Thank you in advance. We really appreciate it. We're grateful to all of you who listen and watch and vote for us. If you have thoughts, feelings, concerns, if you are mad at me for using Muse and want to talk about it, I would absolutely love to hear from you. Vergecasterge.com is the email. [music] 86611 is the Vergecast hotline. Send us everything. I want to know what you're using these things for. I want to know what you feel gross using these things for. I want to know if you just won't use them on principle. I This stuff is so new and so different. I want to hear all about it. Get at [music] us. And as a reminder, the best thing you can do to support all of this always is to subscribe to The Verge. The verge.com/subscribe. It gets you all of our podcast adree, including this one. It gets you all of our subscriber exclusive newsletters, everything the Verge does. The verge.com/subscribe. [music] Thanks in advance. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Josh Kahas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kefir, and Travis Larch. We will see you tomorrow. Rock and roll. [music]